Anna Kraft, LPC
There are so many things that hold us back from learning how to trust yourself. I used to think overthinking was one of my better qualities.
Seriously. I told myself it meant I was thorough. Responsible. That I cared enough to consider every angle before acting. What I didn’t realize for a long time was that I wasn’t actually looking for clarity — I was looking for certainty. And certainty, for an overthinker, is a moving target. You can spend hours inside a decision and still walk away feeling like you missed something.
Every choice — even the small ones — starts to feel weighted. Like something is always on the line.
The Fear Underneath the Analysis
I came across Joseph Nguyen’s The Overthinker’s Guide to Making Decisions and one line stopped me cold: “The root of overthinking is fear.”
It was uncomfortable to read, honestly. Because I’d spent a lot of time telling myself that all that analyzing was protecting me. But when I sat with it, I recognized what was actually happening. Underneath all the research, the pros-and-cons lists, the replayed conversations — there was fear. Fear of regret. Fear of getting it wrong. Fear that one bad call would somehow define me, or disappoint the people I cared about.
Overthinkers, in my experience, tend to be deeply sensitive people. People who notice everything. Who care — about outcomes, about relationships, about how their choices ripple outward. That kind of awareness can be a real strength. But at some point, for a lot of us, that awareness started functioning more like a threat detector than a superpower. The questions shifted from what do I want? to what’s the safest thing I can do?
And the thing about “safe” decisions is that they often just mean no decision at all.
Why More Thinking Doesn’t Actually Help
Here’s the part that took me the longest to accept: no amount of thinking creates certainty. It feels like it should. It feels productive — like if I just sit with it a little longer, I’ll finally land on the right answer and feel at peace with it. But that peace never comes from more analysis. It just creates more noise.
Eventually, you stop trusting yourself entirely. And that’s where things get really heavy.
Fear and Intuition Don’t Sound the Same
One of the most useful reframes I’ve encountered is the distinction between fear and intuition. They can feel similar — both show up during high-stakes moments, both feel urgent — but they’re doing very different things.
Fear is loud. It catastrophizes. It says what if this ruins everything? or you’ll regret this or don’t risk it. Intuition is quieter. It doesn’t usually yell. It tends to feel more like a steady pull toward something honest, even when that something is also a little scary.
Nguyen puts it simply: “The mind thinks, but intuition knows.”
The problem is that chronic overthinkers often learn to dismiss that quieter voice early on. We’re taught to prioritize logic, outside opinions, or the appearance of certainty over our own internal knowing. But sometimes the most aligned choice isn’t the one that feels safest. Sometimes it’s just the one that feels most like you.
A Framework for When You Feel Stuck
Nguyen offers something called the TRUST framework, and I find it genuinely useful — not because it eliminates hard decisions, but because it slows the spiral down enough to actually hear yourself think.
T — Take five deep breaths. Not as a magic fix, but because an anxious nervous system is a terrible decision-maker. Slowing down physiologically first gives you a better shot at accessing something other than panic.
R — Reveal the root decision. Overthinking turns one decision into forty imagined catastrophes. Strip it back. What is the actual choice in front of you, separated from all the stories you’ve wrapped around it?
U — Uncover the fear and its cost. Ask yourself honestly: what am I actually afraid of here? And — this part matters — what is staying stuck costing me? Indecision isn’t neutral. It has a price too.
S — Shift from fear to intuition. Instead of asking what’s the safest option? try asking which choice feels most aligned with who I want to become? Those are very different questions. And they usually lead somewhere different. Growth tends to feel a little scary before it feels freeing.
T — Take the smallest possible action. You don’t have to have everything figured out first. You just need the next honest step. Send the email. Make the call. Say the thing. Small actions build something overthinkers genuinely need more of: proof that you can trust yourself.
Confidence Isn’t What You Think It Is
I still second-guess myself. I don’t think that fully goes away. But I’m slowly learning that confidence in decision-making isn’t about always choosing right — it’s about believing you can handle whatever comes next, even when you don’t know what that is yet.
That shift is quieter than it sounds. But it changes a lot.
If you’re someone who turns every decision into an endurance sport — know that it makes sense that you got here. A mind that learned to hyperanalyze everything probably had good reasons for doing so at some point. That doesn’t mean you have to keep living inside it.
Learning to trust yourself is slow, honest work. But it might be some of the most important work you do.
Reach Out Now
We look forward to connecting with you!
